‘Pretty’ Review: The Ambition Is There. The Movie Isn’t There Yet
There is something admirable about a 19-year-old medical student deciding he wants to make a horror movie and then basically saying, “Fine, I’ll do the whole damn thing myself.”
Metecan Duren wrote, directed, produced, shot, edited, and composed the score for Pretty, his debut feature which stars Saran Duren, Melisa Kihtir, and Omer Gursoy. That kind of commitment matters. Filmmaking is expensive, collaborative, exhausting, and usually dependent on access to people and resources most young filmmakers simply do not have. Sometimes the only way to make the thing is to grab whoever is willing, use what you have, and figure it out. I respect that.

The problem is that Pretty, in its current state, is nearly unwatchable. The film follows a young woman who becomes obsessed with uncovering the murder of a girl after making contact with her ghost. From there, the story moves into jealousy, murder, strange occurrences, and supernatural horror. At least, that is what the film is trying to do.
Visually, it is often so dark that I genuinely could not tell what I was looking at. Horror can absolutely live in darkness, but there is a difference between controlled shadow and simply not being able to see the scene. Too much of Pretty falls into the latter. Another hurdle is the performances.
The actors often deliver their lines in a flat, deadpan rhythm that drains scenes of tension rather than building it. Horror especially needs calibration. Fear, suspicion, grief, unease, paranoia. These things have to register somewhere, even if the performance is restrained. Here, too many scenes feel like people are reciting dialogue rather than living through something. That becomes a larger directing issue.
When you are writing, directing, shooting, editing, producing, composing, and presumably solving every other problem on set, you lose the benefit of another pair of eyes telling you something is not working. That is not a failure of ambition. It is one of the dangers of being a one-man band. You become too close to the material.

What is frustrating is that I do think there is potential underneath all of this. The premise works. The obsession with a murdered girl, the supernatural intrusion, and the love-and-jealousy angle could make for a nasty little horror story with the right tightening. Honestly, Pretty might even work better as a short or vertical film. The story feels suited to something more compressed and immediate, where Duren could focus on atmosphere, one or two strong performances, and a limited number of locations instead of trying to sustain a feature.
I am not particularly interested in dunking on a teenage filmmaker for making an imperfect movie. Making any movie at 19 takes nerve, but effort and quality are not the same thing. Pretty shows that Duren has ideas and the willingness to put them on screen. Now he needs collaborators who can help him see what he cannot.
Categories
Valerie Complex View All
Writer, Critic, and passionate about comics, movies and equality on the big screen.